shipping icon

pickup icon

We ship Monday-Thursday, see shipping FAQ. PLEASE enter the complete shipping address including unit # and CORRECT zipcode. Without an accurate address, transit delays will occur, UPS may not deliver. UPS charges $22 for each incomplete address or zipcode. Inclement weather WILL cause transit delays. Estimated transit times are NOT guaranteed by UPS & FEDEX. We are cookie makers, not freight experts. Please be nice:))

black n' white: but better!!

Product image 1black n' white: but better!!
Product image 2black n' white: but better!!
Product image 3black n' white: but better!!
Product image 4black n' white: but better!!
Product image 5black n' white: but better!!

Regular price $ 28.00

Have you tried to love traditional NY deli style black and white cookies? Not quite a muffin top, not a soft cookie, not cake and most times a teeny bit...shall we say stale?  Big.Fat.Cookie decided the time has come to shake things up bit in the black and white cookie arena.  

Presenting  Big.FLAT. B/W.  Not for diehard traditional black and white fans.  

Our take on the black and white cookie is made with a tender short bread base, topped with vanilla and cocoa meringue glaze, and our favorite big.fat.cookie toppings.

Each 4" cookie is large enough to share or cut into pieces and savor alone! 

Teeny black and whites are 3 bites, you won't want to share.

Little fat black and whites are 3 bites of peanut butter and chocolate mix!

Cookies arrive ready to enjoy. Keeps at room temperature for 10 days. Enjoy at room temperature.

Little fats can be frozen and warmed according to enclosed instructions.

gift ready means: package arrives ready to give as a gift.

packed for you means, no frills packing, packed for you!

Choose from options below

  • Pack of four 4" tender short bread cookies + vanilla and cocoa meringue glaze & rainbow sprinkles {gift ready}
  • Pack of EIGHT mini black and whites+ rainbow sprinkles { packed for you}
  • Pack of SIXTEEN mini black and white+ rainbow sprinkles {gift ready}
  • Pack of SIXTEEN little fats peanut butter+ triple black and white top {gift ready}

Made with slowly and carefully browned, not burned butter, Chicago's big.fat.cookie takes on a New York staple: the black and white. Our shortbread cookie + meringue glaze will make you wonder, "What took them so long?"

BIG.FLAT.Black and whites will make you the hit of the office party, first date, family reunion, Summer BBQ, Thanksgiving feast, day after your friend breaks up, or just get them for yourself!  Individually wrapped for freshness  (PLUS our stickers are really cool!!!)  1 serves 2 (but if you eat it by yourself, we won't judge!!!!)

Big.FLAT. black and whites are best eaten at room temperature and  have a shelf life of 12 days, after that we suggest freezing.

To eat from frozen: take cookies from freezer an hour before eating, we do not recommend warming.

Made in a kitchen with peanuts and tree nuts. 

Contains or may contain: wheat flour, butter, powdered sugar ( corn starch) white sugar, eggs, milk, salt, vanilla extract, meringue glaze: egg whites, sugar, water, cocoa powder, puppy chow: peanut butter, semi sweet chocolate, rice chex cereal, powdered sugar, Oreos

Close (esc)

wanna learn about new big.fat.stuff?

join our email...promise not to stalk you:)

Age verification

By clicking enter you are verifying that you are old enough to consume alcohol.


Shopping Cart

Your cart is currently empty.
Shop now